This is a slightly shorter review than usual because I am buried in work. However, that doesn't mean this wasn't a very good episode. As a matter of fact, for me it was the best episode of the series so far. We finally got to see the contestants create food that really looked exciting and delicious and top-quality-restaurant-ish, as a collective. And, my girl Lee Anne won the elimination challenge, finally!
In the Quick challenge the contestants had to make an appetizer with ingredients that cost less than $3. A very good test of their culinary skills, I thought. It brought about my one disappointement about this show: Ted Allen, the food expert of the Queer Eye gang, selected Stephen's chi-chi presentation of itty bitty bits of food and painted on sauce and stuff over what I thought were 3 better looking plates, for the quick challenge. As The Tom points out in his BravoTV blog , Stephen is doing nothing new here - he's merely imitating chefs who have blazed the trail of food-as-art presentations. As much as I like beautiful plates of food, these food-pictures turn me off..they are too precious. Not that Stephen doesn't have talent, but at this stage in his career he lacks true originality and understanding of good food. Though that really makes him perfect for Las Vegas. (I have never been impressed by the expensive restaurants in Vegas, but that's for another time.)
I really liked the look of Harold's dish; the combination of crispy bacon with the bitterness of the treviso (which is a kind of radicchio) really sounded good. And Lee Anne's Deep Fried Oysters with Lemon Garlic Cream looked yummy too (there is a recipe on the BravoTV site .) I was a bit less enthusiastic about Tiffani's Oysters Three Ways thing...it was a bit too Stephen-ish for me.
The main challenge, where they had to work together to produce a seven-course dinner for Ted Allen's book launch party, was what made this show so good though. Having the contestants work on a whole dinner, each handling one course, was interesting enough. But then the producers threw in a great twist - instead of cooking the course they had planned and shopped for, they had to draw straws - er, rather, knives - to pick another course to actually cook. None of them were happy about this but the one who really went off the deep end was Miguel, who mistakenly put salt instead of sugar in the beet sorbet he was making (based on Lee Anne's recipe). He sort of rescued the course in the end, but it's clear that laid-back, fun-loving Miguel is retreating further and frantic, slightly desperate Miguel is coming to the fore. I guess that being a hotel banquet chef is not the best for advancing your career as a top chef, so winning this competition would probably mean more for him than almost anyone else.
In the end though, it was Andrea who was eliminated, for the second time. She deserved to go because she really didn't want to win anyway. Everyone else left in the competition clearly wants it badly. So off she's gone into the happy land of food that induce Bowel Movements. The winner was Lee Anne, who did an excellent job with Tiffani's duck and fig-stuffed gnocchi dish. Tiffani and Stephen were the other top three. I would love to see a Lee Anne vs. Tiffani all-girl final. (If Top Chef follows the pattern of Project Runway, chances are there will be 3 finalists. In which case, I want to see Tiffani, Lee Anne and Harold in there.)